I called a British friend of mine to meet me for lunch at The Old Bag of Nails Pub and explained that this was one of my favorite go-to places for authentic Fish and Chips.  Surprised by the name, he said he thought that this was a coffee shop rather than a restaurant. I guessed he was confusing the restaurant with Chock Full O’Nuts…who knows, but we agreed that the Hilliard location was closest for both of us.

I quickly learned, through the magic of the internet, that this restaurant had originally opened in a former hardware store, so hence the name, The Old Bag of Nails.  Regardless, you can’t go wrong with pub food and a pint.

Located on the corner of Norwich and Main Street in Old Hilliard, the restaurant is easily accessible with plenty of parking spaces.   Graham was waiting as I parallel parked and we were quickly seated at a nearby booth. Handed our menus, we each placed our order for a pint of Guinness.

Although I usually know what I am going to order, I am always tempted to order the all you can eat fish and chips.  There are two options which include fried cod or baked cod with a dill dip.  The portions are unbelievably large, with two pieces of fried fish.  Just thinking about the fried fish batter makes my mouth water.  It is served with coleslaw,  tartar sauce and a side of French fries that could feed a family of five.  I love to add malt vinegar to both the fish and fries.

I can hardly eat the first piece of fried fish, but my server brings me a piece of baked fish so that I can try it.  The dill dip that comes with the baked option really compliments the flavor of the cod.  I’m glad I tried it, but now I’m wondering how I could feel so full.  I want to blame the fish, but then again, it could be the ale. Yes, it was probably the ale.  I guess I’ll just have to go home and take a nap.

Have you had the opportunity to visit The Old Bag of Nails Pub?  Besides the fish and chips, what other menu items are your favorite?  I would love to hear from you if you would kindly leave a message in the comments section below!

Where to Eat:

The Old Bag of Nails Pub
4065 Main Street
Hilliard, Ohio 43026
Telephone:  614 777 0713

You can’t go wrong with the best Fish & Chips in town!

Disclosure:   Please refer to our blog disclaimer tab for more information.

  The Bar at The Old Bag of Nails Pub

Inside the Old Bag of Nails Pub in Old Hilliard, Ohio